Review for "Disco: Running Commodity Operating Systems on Scalable Multiprocessors"

From: Justin Voskuhl (justinv_at_microsoft.com)
Date: Mon Mar 01 2004 - 15:02:30 PST

  • Next message: Cem Paya 98: "Review: Disco"

    Disco is a virtual machine monitor that runs on top of a non-uniform
    memory access computer at Stanford called FLASH. FLASH is built out of
    MIPS processors and has a set of processing units that communicate with
    each other over an interconnect that allows it to simulate a shared
    memory multiprocessor. Because such hardware needs software to be
    useful, but building an OS from scratch or extending existing operating
    systems is very expensive, the authors propose a way to virtualize
    existing operating systems to allow them to run on the new hardware.
    Disco provides a number of facilities that are used to enhance the
    performance of the memory, disk, and network. The first is to be smart
    about where to locate pages - it tries to keep them closest to the PE
    that is using the most. The disks performance is enhanced by using
    copy-on-write semantics so many disk requests can be satisfied
    immediately by mapping pages from already loaded disk blocks into the
    address space of a guest OS. The network is made more performant by
    having a special area of memory that allows clients and servers using
    NFS to coordinate using NFS semantics but instead of sending and
    receiving messages on the network, it uses a shared block of memory.

     

    One thing that strikes me about this paper is that to some degree the
    purpose of having such cutting edge hardware should be to tackle new and
    interesting problems that can't be solved on conventional systems. If
    you saddle developers with the old OS (even with the extensions
    described) then you're still somewhat limited in the new problems you
    can solve with it. Disco is neat, but I just can't see how you justify
    building a system like FLASH just to run emacs on top of IRIX on top of
    Disco to edit your e-mail.


  • Next message: Cem Paya 98: "Review: Disco"

    This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.6 : Mon Mar 01 2004 - 15:02:36 PST